Burnt Mountain by Anne Rivers Siddons

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Even in early days, Thayer felt out of place in her own home. For while her older sister gravitated to shopping for pretty dresses and searching through the fashion magazines treasured by her mother, Thayer was much more likely to be found shoeless, in shorts and tee shirt, at her little makeshift hideaway by the river. While she cared little for fashion, she did love her books, and she adored both her father and grandmother, who both appreciated her for who she was. When a tragedy befell her family, Thayer knew she could turn to her grandmother, and her grandmother was truly there for her. Or was she?

This story began, as most of those written by Siddons, as a beautiful novel that created characters that we love right from the start. Thayer is at once spirited and shy, smart and awkward, and we bond with her and feel for her from the first word. And through the first several chapters, we are still with her as she struggles, experiences her first love, and loss, and tragedy. But the novel then takes a turn toward the bizarre, and that is where I begin to lose my connection to the story. While I still feel for Thayer, the other characters grow so dark and the plot line so vague, that it becomes almost disconnected to reality itself. And yes, I can believe that people can be dark and evil – I live in this world – but this is just suddenly and so weirdly so that it is hard to remain on board.

I am usually such a fan of Siddons’ writing, so this was a bit of a disappointment. I suppose every one of her books can’t be perfect, can they?

On to the next book, I guess!

Outer Banks by Anne Rivers Siddons

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Kate was not rich, but from a young age, she was groomed by her father to appear so, in order to fit in with those who are. Because of this, she had an aura of grace which those around her in her Southern college sorority – particularly the hapless Fig – sought to emulate. Although she treasured the bonds that grew between her closest friends – Cecie, Ginger, even Fig – something came between them that shocked even Kate. Now, after 30 years, she is being drawn back in – to see them all once again, to reminisce, to delve back in to those memories. Can she do it? Can she go back there, in spite of the pain? Only with a plan…

Anne Rivers Siddons had a gift for creating characters so authentic that they seem to jump out of the page and speak to our hearts. The four friends and their adolescent relationships were depicted as naturally as any that exist in any dorm room across the country, with their typical jealousies, the drunken banter, and the timeless dreams and anxieties that have blessed and cursed women in colleges since women have attended colleges. Likewise, the character of the older Kate, with her knowing cynicism and untrusting fears, is similarly relatable and sympathetic.

This is a beautifully written story, a timeless tale of young women who create a complicated past for themselves, and who ultimately come together to remember and to forget. But it is a story that the reader will remember long after the last page has been turned.