This is my online book club… Please let me know what you think about the books I’m reviewing. I’d love to hear your opinion!
I’m also always looking for the next book to read. Please help me compile a list of great books with your suggestions right here in the comments for this post…
Livia has had to come to terms with her lot in life. She has created a path through for herself now, married to the sweet Charlie Cable, who toils away on their farm while Livia gives piano lessons to both children and adults in her small, Tennessee town. When Livia receives a call from Sigurd, a man she’s not seen in decades but who can still rile her, her traumatic past comes ringing back in her ears, threatening to disturb the peace she has managed to find.
Here is yet another stunningly beautiful novel by one of my favorite authors. The writing, from the very first few sentence, is gorgeous – prose embellished with the imagery and grace of poetry and music. There are musical analogies everywhere, in keeping with the story that Livia has to tell. And there is heartache too, but told with so much heart.
One prominent theme is generational trauma, that which is carried down from mother to daughter, and again from daughter to daughter. How can a mother parent with love and affection when she has never experienced what that feels like herself? Of course, there are some who manage it, but I imagine that there may be other significant people in their lives who have mentored, who’ve shown them what loving parenting looks like. If you have no exposure, it would be no surprise that it doesn’t happen naturally.
Of course this is another MUST READ – pure symphony of words.
Rachelle and Matthew Brettler are just trying to keep their son, Zac, on track, but it feels as if he’s lost to them. While he was a lovely, happy, albeit quirky child, he’s grown to be a dissatisfied, almost truculent 19-year-old. Once they receive the news that he’s gone missing, they engage the British police and anyone else who might be able to help. When they learn that he has fallen to his death from the terrace of an apartment of a “business associate,” they begin a journey that can only be described as tragic.
This non-fiction depiction of an unsolved crime – the loss of a wayward son – is as heart-wrenching as it is angering. There has clearly been foul play associated with Zac’s death, and the police do not seem to be in any hurry to uncover it. Zac himself is not completely innocent. He’s been posing as the son of a wealthy oligarch who has lost his father and is in a dispute with his mother (all fabricated). In doing so, he has made connections with seemingly wealthy businessmen who are interesting in having him invest in their dealings. On the other hand, he is a 19 year old who has insinuated himself with devious actors, who themselves have been manipulating others for their own financial benefit. Getting to the bottom of what happened in the apartment just prior to his death – which has been labeled a suicide – is at the heart of this great mystery.
The underlying story here is utterly tragic. It is complicated and layered and ultimately frustrating. The reader cannot help feeling for these parents who are just seeking answers, justice. Nevertheless, I found the writing here to be dense and circuitous – perhaps necessarily so because of the complexity of the case – but I found myself getting tangled in the weeds of the story, with its many offshoots and sub-stories. There is a lot of detail here, which both deepens the power of the story and slows it down.
What is apparent, however, is that the British criminal justice system is just as plagued with corruption as the US system. Their police are just as vulnerable to the pressures of bribes as ours. And they have just as complex an underworld as we do here, given the drug world, the world of the ultra-rich (in the form of Russian oligarchs for this story), and the interrelationship of the police/informant dependency. It is perhaps the same world-wide.
Still, I felt this is an important read. I have lived my life feeling insulated from this underbelly of our society; however, it can be any one of us who is poisoned by its tentacles, wittingly or unwittingly. This book is an effective wakeup call for us all.
Margo is not in a good place. After a brief and lukewarm affair with her English professor, she finds herself pregnant, poor, and effectively kicked out of college. How will she be able to care for her baby and also earn a living to support him? It turns out, Margo is much more creative than she’d ever imagined. Why, then, is everyone around her so judgmental?
This is a fun romp of a read, but with a bit more substance than you might expect. I love that it calls out the hypocrisy of our absurd governmental system of ignoring the concept of child care for working parents. So many are caught up in our national Catch-22 of both parents needing to work in order to afford to live, but also not subsidizing child care such that usually one parent’s salary goes toward that child care. And if one is a single parent, and heaven forbid they are not especially trained/educated, they are in a total bind. And of course, this onus most commonly falls onto the mother.
I also love that it calls out the hypocrisy of a society that doesn’t support women – either by laying obstacles to abortion or by not providing support for those who wish to keep pregnancies – but who mostly disdain sex work. Women have been having to resort to using this means of support since there have been women, and yet it is not acknowledged that many find no alternative.
These messages are delivered in a package with a well-paced plot, charming characters, and wry humor. A truly delightful read!
Jean Dornan has been living her life, almost in a fog. She is in a lackluster marriage, living in New Jersey and working as a court reporter, when her world is suddenly burst open by an invitation she receives. She is shocked to see she’s been invited to a retirement party for David Harwell, the professor who was in charge of the French summer history program she’d done during college. As she contemplates actually attending, in spite of the fact that the party will be in France, all of her memories come rushing back: her first love, her illicit affair with the professor, and the heartbreak of their reality. And who would know better about such an affair but Monica Lewinsky???
I found this novel to be unfortunate. The writer clearly has talent and imagination. The initial development of her idea is amusing. The conjuring of the specter of Monica Lewinsky, a victim both of an abuse of power and a disproportionate public shaming, is a relevant and farcical image. However, the backstory, which takes up most of the novel, becomes rambling, predictable, even whiny. We can see exactly where it is going and what will happen. And while a young crush can be obsessive – often is – it is not fun going through that journey with this particular character (Jean). It is just too repetitive and Jean proves to be a less-than-lovable character.
So while it began as a hopeful read, it was hard to stay with it. I did, but not sure it was worth the effort.
Madeline, Celeste, Jane, Renata and Bonnie have been friends for quite a while. It is almost miraculous, as they’ve shared a major trauma that might have split the group. But when Madeline, the outspoken, if slightly distracted, leader of their group plans a splashy bash for her own fiftieth birthday, they are all there to support her. Little does she know what surprises lay ahead of her during and after this party. And how it will all tie into the mysterious package their kids’ high school principal has received.
This sequel to Big Little Lies was one of the hardest novels for me to summarize – and I know I did not do it justice. There are so many intertwined stories, with threads winding not only around the friends but also around their teenage children – and every one of them ties in with another. To further complicate the plot, there is the underlying mystery that their children, students at the local high school, become embroiled in. It is all an ingenious tangle of threads, each captivating in its own right, and each intertwined with each other. And while the twists are not shocking, they are still written with such warmth and humor – and a bit of horror – that they keep you wanting more throughout this delightful narrative.
Moriarty absolutely has a gift for storytelling – and it is on full display here. I don’t want to give anything away, so I won’t go on, but do yourself a favor and read this one! I promise you will enjoy it!
It’s no secret that Lucy has never been close to her mother-in-law, Diana. In fact, while she has always wished for the ideal mother-in-law – someone with whom she might share recipes and inside jokes – she feels she inherited the exact opposite of that. Nevertheless, she is still caught off-guard when two police show up at her home to break the news to her and her husband that Diana has died and that the circumstances of her death are under suspicion…
This is one of those wonderful novels where you think you see where it is going but you are completely wrong (at least I was!). The story beautifully illustrates how what you see on another person’s surface may not at all be who they are underneath. We are first introduced to the characters from Lucy’s perspective, and we feel compassion, even pity for her, particularly where Diana is concerned. Once the narrative switches and we hear Diana’s backstory and perspective, we have a whole new understanding of her life, her circumstances, and her motivations. It is a powerful lesson.
The plot is also quite intricate, built not only by going back and forth primarily between these two characters, but also back in time. Each woman, strong in her own right, is a product of her time, which makes it harder for them to connect, to warm to each other. They have each formed their very differing ideas on how to parent and how to relate to others, by their generational influences and life experiences. Their challenge is how to bridge this gap.
I highly recommend this novel. Excellent writing, great characters, and a suspenseful surprising plot. All the things!
Current day: Willa is trying desperately to keep it together. She and her husband have both lost their positions and they’ve just moved to a small town in NJ where her husband is working below his potential, her grown children are forever battling, and she is fretting over their new house which has just been diagnosed a disaster. Her only hope seems to come from the possibility that she can establish a historical significance to the old house, such that she might earn a grant to help rebuild.
1870’s: Thatcher Greenwood considers himself fortunate to be newly married to the beautiful Rose, and they’ve just been restored to the family home, built by her father. Thatcher is the new high school science teacher and he feels he owes it to the young minds of his students to teach them the most current evidence on evolution, the controversial theory that is challenging the religious secular leaders of their small NJ town. His only ally seems to be their next door neighbor, Mary Treat, a woman seen as odd by her local peers, but who is a brilliant naturalist in her own right. And of course, the family challenge is to keep the peace even as their house is literally falling apart around them.
As always, Barbara Kingsolver has managed to construct a clever and challenging narrative. The two timelines keep the story moving along in parallel, and where one leaves off, the other seems to tie in, even when the stories and the characters differ widely. Looking deeper, however, one cannot help but see the symbol of the home, the foundation; and just as one fears a crumbling of the home, man is fearful of any change, but particularly one that challenges his foundational beliefs. For just as the townspeople of the 1870’s story try to hold on to the biblical creation explanation of how fauna and flora came to being in the face of the evidence for Darwin’s evolution theory, many living today deny that the world is at risk of horrifying consequences from climate change in spite of the overwhelming evidence that the earth is warming and impacting our present let alone our future. Both are based in the same root of fear; both deny solid evidence, science, truth.
And as always, Kingsolver creates beautiful characters to relay her message. Willa, the wife and mother who narrates the current story, is particularly endearing. She is coping with the disaster of her home even while trying to help support her two children, each dealing with past and current trauma. As she struggles to maintain patience with everyone around her, we find ourselves inhaling even as she does, crying and laughing and loving along with her.
On the other hand, in my opinion, there is a bit too much scientific detail in the 1870’s story. I understand that Mary Treat must be given the respect she deserves. In so doing, there is much in the way of clarifying her experiments and observations, her contributions to the data upon which Darwin and other scientists base their writings. And of note, she is a real person and did, in fact, contribute years of scientific data to the ones who assumed the credit (men, of course). However, even I, someone with a scientific background, found some of the detail to be a bit too much.
Overall, however, this was an intricately constructed, beautifully executed novel that was both rich and enriching. Truly outstanding, and, as such, a MUST READ.
Sallie has always felt dominated by her younger, prettier, and more charming sister, Addie. And now that her reputation has been tarnished by embarrassing circumstances limiting both their marriage prospects, she is truly under her sister’s aggressive thumb. When Addie begins to fall for one of the newcomers to their tiny town – one of a set of conjoined twins who hale from Siam and have proven themselves able farmers and businessmen – she recruits Sallie to consider a life with these two men. Even as Sallie cannot even fathom what their lives will be like, she agrees to the match and life as she knows it is forever altered.
This is a truly wild story, based on the lives of distant cousins of the author. While all the details of their actual lives are not known in full, Baker Kline has researched their history and created a narrative from the perspective of one of the wives of these once famous conjoined twins. Two added dimensions to the story are the timing – the mid-1800’s – and their location – a plantation in the South. Even as Sallie is reconciling her very strange arrangement of being married to one of the conjoined twins while her sister is married to the other, she is also grappling with the concept of slavery, the immorality of owning another human being. Even while she is forced to acknowledge her dependence on those who are working for her, she feels in her very bones that it is wrong. When war comes to challenge the family’s “way of life,” she is singularly ready to be rid of this scourge.
I believe the story might have been told through a more abbreviated path, but overall I thought it was a fascinating read, with complex and challenging ideas, and a powerful narrative about difference, acceptance, and courage.
Tilly has suffered a loss she believes she will never get over: the untimely death of the love of her life, her husband Joe. As she dives into her work as an editor, she relinquishes everything else that she loves, even reading for pleasure which had been her favorite pastime. When she receives a call from the owner of a local bookstore saying that he has a package for her, she is baffled by what this could be. What she discovers there is a gift that will change the course of her life, and remind her of the person she still is underneath her grief.
This is a beautiful story, replete with characters who will melt your heart, and with a message so clear and vital. Loss can be devastating, but it is how we cope that determines how the rest of our lives will play out. The bottom line is that we are not weak because we lean on others to get us through; on the other hand, it is often others who will enable us to climb out of the depths of despair. We may just need to find the right ones to do this with us, and that is what this book is about. Support for grief may come from people or experiences that we might never guess are even out there. We just have to open our hearts to possibility (and this may be hard, of course).
One of my favorite characters here is Harper, Tilly’s adventurous and outgoing sister. She adores Tilly and will truly do anything for her. She goes out of her way, if perhaps overreaching a bit in her determination to help Tilly over her sorrow. But she is loyal to her core, and we have to love her for that.
I listened to this book and loved the accents, but I imagine that reading it would also be a lovely experience. Either way, I do recommend this. It’s a lovely story that inspires and heals. (And of course, it encourages reading, which is ALWAYS a good thing!)
Harper is feeling overwhelmed by her many responsibilities and life complications on Martha’s Vineyard: the care of her very ill father, her work – such as it is – and not one but two relationships (both complicated). When her father dies and her estranged twin sister, Tabitha, Tabitha’s daughter, and her own mother come to the memorial service, the secrets Harper has been harboring pretty much explode wide open. On the other hand, life has not been easy for Tabitha either, in her home on Nantucket. She is juggling her flailing business (started by her renowned mother), her out-of-control daughter, who has become a (mean and spoiled) queen bee, even while nursing her own longtime loss. When her father dies, she feels an obligation to attend his memorial service and her life pretty much explodes open as well.
This is another cleverly crafted, fun-but-not-fluffy read from Elin Hilderbrand. The narrative manages to maintain just enough cringe, humor, and painful secrets that it builds into quite a twisted plot involving both sisters. We see how the rival islands, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket personify the rival between the sisters, which in turn echoes the rival between their parents. As their stories are gradually revealed, we learn how secrets can completely undo a family, almost irrevocably.
We also learn how loss can be devastating and how we cope can determine our future happiness. When we allow blame, guilt and regret to overwhelm us, we can cripple ourselves emotionally. On the other hand, when we look inward and find a way toward forgiveness – of ourselves and of others – we may find release. This is not easy and often it may take outside support, but it may be the only way to achieve joy.
Hildebrand has a way of allowing us to meet her beautiful characters, follow them through their twisty journeys, and enjoy the ride alongside them. You may find your heart opening in unexpected ways!