The Identicals by Elin Hilderbrand

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Harper is feeling overwhelmed by her many responsibilities and life complications on Martha’s Vineyard: the care of her very ill father, her work – such as it is – and not one but two relationships (both complicated). When her father dies and her estranged twin sister, Tabitha, Tabitha’s daughter, and her own mother come to the memorial service, the secrets Harper has been harboring pretty much explode wide open. On the other hand, life has not been easy for Tabitha either, in her home on Nantucket. She is juggling her flailing business (started by her renowned mother), her out-of-control daughter, who has become a (mean and spoiled) queen bee, even while nursing her own longtime loss. When her father dies, she feels an obligation to attend his memorial service and her life pretty much explodes open as well.

This is another cleverly crafted, fun-but-not-fluffy read from Elin Hilderbrand. The narrative manages to maintain just enough cringe, humor, and painful secrets that it builds into quite a twisted plot involving both sisters. We see how the rival islands, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket personify the rival between the sisters, which in turn echoes the rival between their parents. As their stories are gradually revealed, we learn how secrets can completely undo a family, almost irrevocably.

We also learn how loss can be devastating and how we cope can determine our future happiness. When we allow blame, guilt and regret to overwhelm us, we can cripple ourselves emotionally. On the other hand, when we look inward and find a way toward forgiveness – of ourselves and of others – we may find release. This is not easy and often it may take outside support, but it may be the only way to achieve joy.

Hildebrand has a way of allowing us to meet her beautiful characters, follow them through their twisty journeys, and enjoy the ride alongside them. You may find your heart opening in unexpected ways!

The Academy by Elin Hilderbrand and her daughter Shelby Cunningham

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

It is September and Move-In Day at Tiffin Academy. It’s a day that would be routine, were it not for the explosive and yet smoothly managed, devastating death of a student the semester prior. As Audre Robinson, Head of School, helps the students get resettled, she cannot stifle her anxiety about how the year will unfold, how the student’s death will impact the returning students, and how the new girl admitted to fill the now open spot will blend in. She also knows school ratings are due to come out this same day. Talk about timing… As the year unfolds, she is also witness to the crazy ways in which the students – and their faculty/staff – get into and out of trouble.

This is a thoroughly entertaining novel, set in a fictional boarding school in the hinterlands of western Massachusetts. We are brought into the daily academic, social and emotional demands of these adolescents as they navigate the intense and privileged environment into which they are thrust. Who is the Queen Bee and how can we earn her good graces? How can we “get with” the cute guy/girl? Mind you, this is not restricted to the students, either. The new hires for English and History bring their own drama to the mix. It gets complicated!

I love that this is written by the author and her daughter. After her older brother chose to attend boarding school, her daughter chose to as well – and her experience and insight into the day-to-day routine, traditions, and culture of this environment provides authentic fodder for the story.

I love also how we see that despite the physical distance from their families, the students are still intertwined with and affected by their family circumstances. Their families continue to impact their mental health and ability to function (or not) in school. This is true both for those with means and those without.

This one is easy to get caught up in! Not so easy to put it down…!

Nantucket Nights by Elin Hilderbrand

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Kayla is getting ready for her 20-year ritual of the annual midnight swim with her two best friends on the island, Antoinette and Val. She understands that they are an unlikely trio – so different in their backgrounds and even their current personalities – but perhaps that is what makes this ritual of going out to their distant point on the island with their champagne and their lobster and their secrets to share so magnetic. She suspects that after the magic, she will likely just return to her routine of worrying that her husband might be cheating on her since she’s put on the pounds of middle age, and that her friends will continue to live the glamorous lives they live. But after Antoinette goes missing during their midnight swim, Kayla’s life – and all of their lives – are anything but routine. Will she ever get back what she has clearly taken for granted?

This is a surprisingly suspenseful novel, told from the perspectives of the various parties involved in Antoinette’s mysterious disappearance – possible drowning – and it holds fast until the very end. While we may find it hard, at first, to find compassion for these characters fortunate enough to live on Nantucket Island where life seems beautiful and luxurious, it is also a small town, with small town competitiveness, petty grievances, and long memories. Nothing happens without everyone knowing about it. There is no anonymity. So while it may be monied, life there comes at a high price.

One issue I have with the story is how it paints women in a stereotypically negative light. The relationships between the three women on the surface appear to be close, but on digging deeper, they are quite catty and competitive. It is utterly adolescent: they cannot possibly be true friends because they are competing for the men, the status, and the “coolness.” Kayla is blindsided by the other two: she is set up, backstabbed by them just because she is the stable and “normal” one. It is high school “mean girls” all over again – but with potentially devastating consequences.

That said, the story is engaging, creative, and does make for an intriguing summer read. Just be sure that if you’re packing it into your beach bag, be sure to swim during the daytime and leave the champagne at home!

Summer People by Elin Hilderbrand

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Beth, and her twins Garrett and Winnie, have just arrived onto Nantucket for the summer. They’ve done this every summer since the twins were born, but this summer is tragically different: they’ve just lost their husband/father in a sudden plane crash. To make things worse, at least in Garrett’s eyes, their father had invited his client’s son, Marcus, to join them on the island for the summer, and Marcus is still coming, even though his family needs this time alone to grieve. When Beth runs into an old boyfriend from years past and invites him and his daughters to join them for dinner soon after they arrive, life gets that much more complicated. And not just for Garrett, but for them all.

This is a story of secrets; that is, how they may be personal or explosive, quietly respected or resentfully detonated. According to Beth, “everyone is entitled to one secret,” but the course of events leads one to wonder if this is true. One may be entitled, and we should all respect this, but things may backfire – and not in a good way.

This is also a story of loss. While the family is coping poorly with their loss, we also feel deeply for Marcus, as he has suffered his own trauma. It was his mother whom the father was defending pro bono to protect her from the death penalty when his plane went down, and Marcus is struggling with his own anger, resentment and sadness. He cannot even bring himself to read the letters she has been writing him from prison. But he grieves quietly, internally, with such composure we worry he might explode.

There is much more to this story than one might imagine. While it does take you to sunnier days, to sandy shores, it is not at all a light summer read. But it is written with warmth and with tenderness, and it captures the imagination as well as your attention throughout.

The Rumor by Elin Hilderbrand

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

Nantucket is a small island – perhaps too small, as those who live there year round seem to run out of things to talk about and perhaps create stories about others that may or may not even be true. For example, when Madeline gets a bit desperate to break her writer’s block and rents a space for herself in which to write, the neighbors begin to buzz about why she might need a place for herself. Just about everything becomes misconstrued, except for the actual, factual controversial actions taking place…

Grab your sunglasses, towel and sunblock, as you will definitely want to bring this one along with you to the beach this summer! This fun, lighthearted novel with its colorful characters, twisty plot, and sarcastic narrative will warm your heart, make you smile, and distract you from all the insanity that is going on in the “real world.” It is just substantive enough to keep you completely intrigued, but yet light enough to not get too anxious or worried about the characters. And really, don’t we have enough anxiety and worry right about now?

If you’re looking for something to read while on vacation – or just looking to feel like you’re on vacation! – here’s just the novel for you!