Orphan Train by Christina Baker Kline (migrated from bookblogger)

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

I’ve been hearing about this book for awhile now… some have said, “Nah, don’t bother” and others have said, “You must read this!”  So I finally read it to see what the fuss was about…  And I’m actually somewhere in between on this one.

The story is an historical fictional account of the orphan trains, the trains that ferried hundreds of orphans under the care of the Children’s Aid Society in NYC to the midwest, to find homes for them.  The children were taken by a few adults who would stop at various train stations and would show the children on a stage, like an auction, and people would come to take them in.  Many were given good homes and an education, but probably many more were used as free labor on farms and in private homes, mistreated and misused.

This particular story is about Molly, who is a foster child who is sentenced to do community service working for an elderly woman, Vivian, helping her to clean out her attic.  As the two delve into the boxes in the attic, Vivian shares her memories of what lies in them and divulges her experiences, through flashbacks, of being an orphan and where her orphan train led her.  The two come to form a close friendship based on their shared experiences.

I think the value of this book does not lie in the quality of the writing, which is only fair,  or even in the character development, which I think is unexpectedly flat.   While Vivian’s story is interesting, it is told in a very clinical, detached way that did not fully engage me; and Molly, who started out as a really interesting character, remained superficial.

The value of the book is really the description of the orphan trains themselves.  I think it is important to know about this dark spot in our history.  The Children’s Aid Society does some extraordinary work with children in foster care today, but its roots are tainted by this cold history.

FOOTNOTE:  If you want to learn about the orphan trains, another book to read is The Chaperone by Liane Moriarty.  It gives slightly less detail about the trains, but it is a beautifully written story that is sure to completely engage you!

The Chaperone (migrated from Bookblogger)

Posted on by marjorieseidenfeld

The Chaperone by Laura Moriarty

More than the beautiful writing and the wonderful character portraits drawn in this book, I loved the message contained in these pages.  In the telling of this story about Cora, a woman with grown children who volunteers to chaperone a bratty teenager, Louise Brooks, to New York City in her quest for stardom, the author so articulately writes the wisdom that the generations can learn from each other.  Cora begins as a fairly stodgy and righteous old coot who is very concerned about maintaining her charge’s reputation.  Louise, on the other hand, is determined to act out and rebel against all of this and does not care at all what anyone thinks.  As the story progresses, however, they both learn that they need to do what they can to make themselves happy and that staying with the status quo does not always accomplish that.

The reader cannot help loving Cora, who is very human and very wise.  There are dilemmas and difficulties in her life that are not what she ever anticipates, but she finds a way to cope and find happiness.  She, in her own way, becomes something of a rebellious one, and she accepts change more than even she would have ever imagined.

The book is also historical fiction, giving the reader a close-up of the small town perspective on the 1920’s through the second world war and beyond.  The social evolution that Cora is a part of is very reflective of the changes occurring during these radical times.  And while Cora is a victim of some of the early prejudices, she becomes something of an instrument of change in her later years.  Her understanding of the urgency for this change to occur is so beautifully summed up by my favorite quote in the book, “she would owe this understanding to her time in New York, and even more to Louise.  That’s what spending time with the young can do — it’s the big payoff for all the pain.  the young can exasperate, of course, and frighten, and condescend, and insult, and cut you with their still unrounded edges.  But they can also drag you, as you protest and scold and try to pull away, right up the the window of the future, and even push you through.”