We Are Water by Wally Lamb

This novel opens with the tragic tale of Josephus Jones, who, living in a shack on the property of his employer, creates art that is only truly appreciated after his tragic death. Years later, on the same property, a new family with its own artist is coming to terms with their changed circumstance: that Annie, the wife, has left her husband, Orion, for her art dealer in Manhattan and they are planning to marry. As the upcoming nuptuals near, they set in motion a collision course that opens wounds and exposes secrets that have been suppressed for decades.

This novel is another brilliant saga, a gift to us from Wally Lamb. There are so many layers to unpack here, but the overarching message, I believe, is the corrosive damage done to us by keeping secrets from loved ones, and avoiding confronting our demons. Annie’s past, while dark and shameful (in her eyes), has been kept secret for so long, but it eats at her and erupts in dangerous ways. The secrets she then imposes upon her children are also damaging, both for her and for them. We see how each of her children cope, often dysfunctionally, in their own ways.

Lamb’s narration is outstanding. By rotating perspective from each of these colorful and dynamic characters and smoothly conforming the phrasing to their unique personalities, we are allowed inside the minds of each one. This enriches the story in a profound way and helps to build suspense as we see what each character sees and doesn’t see, knows and doesn’t know. The build into the later scenes left me breathless, to be honest.

An outstanding novel in so many respects. Do yourself the kindness of allotting time for this one. It’s also a MUST READ, so you kind of have to, right???

Buckeye by Patrick Ryan

One might imagine that in the small town of Bonhomie, OH, it would be hard to keep secrets – even in the early 1940’s, as the town is distracted by the second World War. Nevertheless, Cal and Becky Jenkins, are drifting apart because of differences and broken confidences, and secrets are fomenting between them. Likewise, Felix and Margaret Salt, separated by Felix’s service overseas, are also harboring secrets of their own. How their secrets collide is at the heart of this drama and the tension arises from whether or not they will reveal their respective truths.

There is quite a bit of hype surrounding this novel, as it is on many lists of best books of 2025. I have to say that I am surprised by this, as I found it disappointing. While there are good ideas embedded here, with quite a bit of interesting potential, I found the writing to be flat, the characters not well-developed, and the whole story written almost as if it were a chore to be gotten over with. Dialogue, if present, is completely trite, with so little passing between characters that I wonder why they bother with each other (I wouldn’t). Even when there are supposedly “tender” moments, they are so bland they could pass completely under the radar.

The only character with any color at all, in fact, is Cal’s father, Everett, who is considered a bit wacky by everyone else. He has survived serving in the first World War, and is thrilled that Cal cannot serve in the second because of his leg length discrepancy (something Cal is ashamed of). He has had multiple life traumas and copes by drinking, hoarding, and essentially living as a loner. But he regularly types out letters to the President of the United States that actually articulate (perhaps not in the prettiest language) more sense than most of his more “esteemed” peers, voicing his anti-war, anti-prejudice, and pro-democracy values.

I know others liked this one more than I did – I would love to know why/how. If you’re willing to comment, I’d love to hear your opinion! In the meantime, I am stumped.