It is clear that Kristin Hannah’s writing blossomed dramatically between writing this novel and writing her master work The Nightingale. I was hoping to be drawn into similarly beautifully drawn scenes with intricate plot lines as I was in that great novel – and I was sorely disappointed here. While there started to be an intriguing idea for the story, and it began well enough, it just was not developed with the same sophistication and elegance as that later work.
This story begins with young Bret preparing the saddle early in the morning for his mom, Mikaela, to have her early morning horseback ride. Suddenly, something was noticeably off and Bret watched as his mom started jumped the horse and the horse stopped and Mikaela was thrown forward, banging her head against a pole, sustaining a severe head injury. The next thing they all knew, their lives were thrown upside-down, as Mikaela was in a deep coma and it was unclear if she’d ever recover. What comes after tests the love each of the family members has for each other.
There are some truly brilliant moments in this story and the basic plot is a clever one. The test of love that Mikaela’s husband, Liam, faces is a fascinating ethical dilemma that I think many would find paralyzingly difficult. And there are tender scenes between the various family members that are quite sweet.
However, the writing itself is somewhat simplistic. The plot could be more involved, with more story lines woven into the main one. The characters could be much more multi-dimensional – they are extremely flat – and, wow, is the latter half of the story just pure saccharine-sweetness! It felt as if the author herself got bored with the book about halfway through and just wanted to be over and done with the project, so she wrote whatever came out easily. It was quite anti-climactic.
So, stick with The Nightingale, and forget about this one, I’d say…
After 24 years of marriage, Elizabeth has finally come to terms with the fact that her husband, Jack, and her 2 daughters have all taken center stage in her life, leaving her to cast aside her own dreams and aspirations. When Jack was a famous football star, she cared for her young daughters mostly by herself. When Jack later became a smaller time sports caster, moving from town to town where opportunities arose, she duly followed. But now that the girls are both out of the house, she realizes that it is time for her to attend to herself – she just has to figure out whether that plan will include Jack or not…
This is a story that will, sadly, strike a familiar chord with many readers, I believe. When the nest empties, it is often a challenge for couples to fill the void – or it is the time when the void has to finally be acknowledged. Hannah describes this conflict with sensitivity, honesty and warmth, presenting both Elizabeth’s and Jack’s sides to a complicated story.
I think it was not good that I knew before reading this book that the author had written The Nightingale. That book was so outstanding that I had elevated expectations for this one. For example, some subplots were hinted at but then left undone. One character, Kim, who Elizabeth met in a support group, was a mysterious, moodier member of the group. It appeared that she was going to be more of a presence in the book (and it was an interesting possibility), but she was just sort of abandoned in a more underdeveloped state.
I would still recommend this book – it was a nice read – but manage your expectations if you’ve read The Nightingale!
This is a MUST-read!
Vianne and Isabelle, sisters living in France during the late 1930’s, could not be more different from each other. Vianne is calm, very settled and contented; while Isabelle is impulsive, daring and always desperately seeking attention and love. Both, however, had their lives completely disrupted by the German invasion into France during the advent of the second world war. And both resisted the Germans each in her own very brave way. Through their miserable experiences during the war, they each came to understand each other and respect each other for who they really were and who they each became.
This book, while extremely emotionally difficult to read, was outstanding. The writing was clear and fluid and just explicit enough to get the sordid details across. The characters are beautifully drawn; both sisters became real people for whom I felt a powerful empathy. It also was descriptive but still kept the action moving so that there was never a lull, never a single sentence I wanted to skim over. It is a story that keeps your heart beating at high speed until the very last page.
Once again – a MUST-READ!